Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Low Protein Intake Associated with Lower Risk of Cancer? I Think NOT!



A recent study seems to contradict everything I've said regarding the non-harmful effects of animal proteins. I now stand before the Vegetarian Inquisition. Time to be a man and defend myself!

The Article:  "Low Protein Intake Is Associated with a Major Reduction in IGF-1, Cancer, and Overall Mortality in the 65 and Younger but Not Older Population" (Link Here)

The Major Theses of the Paper

If you follow the link to the article (found above), you'll readily note the highlights of the article -
  1. High protein intake is linked to increased cancer, diabetes, and overall mortality
  2. High IGF-1 levels increased the relationship between mortality and high protein
  3. Higher protein consumption may be protective for older adults
  4. Plant-derived proteins are associated with lower mortality than animal-derived proteins
It seems I've got some work to do.

Addressing Thesis 1

The first conclusion the authors of this study make seems awfully similar to the contention that Campbell makes in The China Study.  If you've been following my series on vegetarianism wherein I've been breaking down Denise Minger's very thorough critique of Campbell's work, you well know of the impossibility of indicting protein (especially animal sources of protein) as if the term "protein" somehow could sufficiently encompass all of the various sources of amino acids in existence.  

Speaking of animal proteins in particular, we already know that the source, and the type of protein from that source, will drastically effect how our bodies react.  For instance, casein protein, which comes from milk, has carcinogenic properties when it is consumed in an environment where other toxins are already present - i.e. when we consume casein along with aflatoxin (which is rampantly prevalent in peanuts).  Whey protein, however, which also comes from milk, has anti-carcinogenic properties.

So, as we can see, we make a rather big mistake when we categorize all animal sources protein into a single group.  The authors of this particular study make this mistake.  They broadly categorize all sources of protein as either animal or plant based.  As the vigilant reader will easily note, certain sources of animal protein don't necessarily represent the panacea of health foods.  I'm of course referring here to processed "franken-meats" (Oscar-Meyer anyone?).  

Something else to keep in mind is that the average American (oh yeah! Did I mention that the authors based their study on "average" Americans, not health conscious omnivores) consumes, not only a plethora of processed meats, but also a variety of processed grain and flower products, along with a variety sugary goods, with these meats - i.e. buns, Doritos, soft drinks, etc.  Such foods likely contributed to the increased risk of cancer mortality among the higher protein groups which the authors examined.

Addressing Thesis 2

So what is IGF-1?  It is merely a shorthand name for insulin-like growth factor 1.  Like its name suggests, IFG-1 is like insulin.  Thus, like insulin, it is an anabolic hormone, related to, among many things, muscle growth and the supply of nutrients to various cells.  

You may now ask:  "If IGF-1 is like insulin, and insulin is spiked by carbs, why are we talking about protein?"

Good question!  In reality, carbohydrates are not the only nutrients which effect insulin.  Protein, too, will spike insulin, and also IGF-1.  So what's so bad about it?  Like any hormone in your body, IGF-1 is good when in the context of balance.  Your body produces a variety of hormones for various biological and survival reasons.  In the proper quantity, these hormones keep you alive and thriving.   In the wrong quantities, they can be chronic stressors.

Intermittent fasting can actually lower IGF-1.
In this particular study, unnaturally high levels of IGF-1 seem correlative with increased risk of mortality.  However, is this increased level related to excess protein consumption, or the actual health of the study participants prior to the test?  IGF-1, interestingly enough, is related to a high body mass index.  Since we've already established that the group in this study which consumed the highest amount of animal protein was also likely consuming other processed junk foods, and, moreover, since we may readily say that such foods are hyper-palatable and thus conducive to over-consumption, the reason the higher protein group had higher levels of IGF-1 was likely due, much in part, if not totally, to the overall poor quality of their diet.  Animal protein, as a broad categorization, likely had nothing to do with the results the authors observed.

Addressing Thesis 3

I actually agree with this component of their study.  I've read some interesting research (though I can't find it at the moment) that suggests that, as people age, their ability to efficiently metabolize dietary protein degrades.  As a result, older individuals may likely need to consume higher quantities of protein in order for them to more easily hold on to their lean mass.  However, as a caveat, one can also more readily hold on to, and build, lean mass by doing some form of intelligently designed resistance training program, even in the context of a low protein diet (Read this article I wrote for more info about this issue - Click Here).

Addressing Thesis 4

To address this point, I would like to direct you to what I said regarding the 1st thesis.

The Verdict?

Inquisition defeated!

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

I Reject Your Meta-Narrative & Substitute My Own!



Meta-narrative - otherwise known as a story of everything - completely saturates many dietary "camps."  Vegans, low-carbers, paleo dieters, keto dieters, raw food dieters, etc. each and all have particular stories to tell about the food we eat and how said food affects our lives.

I won't lie here, in my study and evaluation of several different dieting strategies and philosophies, the temptation to join this or that school of nutrition dogma (by dogma, I mean theoretical principles only - I mean nothing degrading nor derogatory) has proved quite powerful.  Moreover, my disdain for certain schools of thought is readily apparent by my as yet uncompleted series on vegetarianism (which I promise I will eventually finish).

While regular readers may think that I have a special place in my heart for the paleo cause, I have failed,
many-a-time, to reveal my subtle dislike for paleo.  Although, to put things in a more accurate light, I don't have misgivings about any one dietary school per se.  Rather, I only reject their respective meta-narratives - that being each camps' story about all things healthful and harmful.

I reject their meta-narratives for 2 reasons:  1)  I've found bad in most all dietary philosophies; 2)  I've found good in most all dietary philosophies.  This rather oxymoronic discrepancy tells me one very important thing:  that many dietary philosophies are on to some "truth," meanwhile, the meta-narratives these philosophies use to orient us toward this truth somehow miss a very crucial component of it.

In my opinion, if a meta-narrative for diet is really going to be a comprehensive story of all things healthful and harmful, then points of misalignment cannot exist within this story's framework.

So what are points of misalignment for paleo?:  That not everyone, at all times and all places, ought to give up eating grain based goods.  While many people who go down the paleo path experience great health benefits by avoiding whole grain foods like the plague, not all people share this same experience.  Low-carb diets, especially, have a number of misalignments in their meta-narratives.  While restricting carbohydrates may work quite well for a sedentary, overweight/obese individual, a low carb diet might spell disastrous effects for an active, relatively fit and thin person who weight trains and does high intensity interval training on a regular basis.  Low carb works wonders under a certain set of parameters, but it can do great harm within a different context.

The problem, therefore, with most dietary meta-narratives arises from their lack of nuance.  Advocates of given schools have extensive lists of "medicines" and "poisons."  However, what is medicine but the proper dose of poison?  As the ancient Greeks tell us, "let food be thy medicine, and let medicine be thy food."  If medicine equals the right dose of poison, and poison the improper dose medicine, and if medicine should be our food, then the healthfulness or harmfulness of any food is a matter of dose.

So then you ask:  "Tell me wiseguy.  What is the right dose?"

My answer:  "Whatever doesn't kill you!"

Put more practically, we can know the right and wrong dose based on how our body reacts.  If we start putting on unwanted weight, we know that our dose of food is too high.  However, the dose which leads to such weight gain will vary from person to person.  Olympic athletes have to consume upwards of 6,000-12,000 calories a day just to maintain their weight and their performance.  If I ate that much in a day, I'd be a fat tub of lard.

Think about it this way:  would a doctor prescribe the same dose of a certain medicine to a 100lb woman as he would a 225lb man?  To do so would be absurd!  In the same manner, prescribing a low carb diet to a competitive athlete would, in effect, "poison" said athlete, at least in terms of said athlete's performance and hormone regulation.

Thus, we need to replace our paleo, vegan, low carb, high carb, semi-high carb, high protein, low protein, etc. meta-narratives with the doctor's meta-narrative.  This meta-narrative entails that we self-prescribe dietary strategies that accord with our unique goals and food tolerances.  Someone who is not wheat sensitive, but who easily succumbs to hyper-palatable food (i.e. - someone who readily overeats when exposed to pizza, brownies, cookies, ice cream - basically all the foods that cause me overeat :( ), may be
able to easily get away with having brownies once or twice a month to no ill effect.  Someone who is wheat sensitive, however, depending on the severity of the sensitivity, may have to avoid brownies altogether.

The paleo meta-narrative automatically assumes the latter situation (that we need total abstinence).  The "doctoral" meta-narrative allows for both possibilities (whether one can or cannot have a brownie is subjective).

It's easy to fall within a given dietary meta-narrative and, from there, make universal prescriptions of healthful and harmful foods.  It's incredibly hard to be a doctor.  Being a doctor requires practice.  Not only do you have to know certain aspects of nutrition and fitness, but you also have to know what's relatively nutritious and fit within a given context; whether that context be your unique situation or your next door neighbor's.

So what meta-narrative will you choose?

I plan to be a doctor (like one anyway), rather than a patient, because frankly, I don't have the patience (pun intended) to put up with a faulty meta-narrative that doesn't apply to me in my unique situation.

Saturday, March 1, 2014

The Ultimate Back Workout


What's the best back workout, hands down, for building a bigger, stronger back?  Read on to find out....

Many would-be gym rats often make the major mistake of focusing solely on the "mirror" muscles - i.e. the chest and biceps.  As a result, these trainees often neglect the musculature of the back (and to their detriment I might add).  By overemphasizing the chest, an imbalanced ratio of pushing-to-pulling arises, thus leading to a host of shoulder injuries down the road.  

Beyond the unhealthful implications of eschewing back work (think hunched shoulders and chronic scapular depression), many unfavorable anatomical/physique oriented issues arise as well (imagine having a rock hard chest, but a soft, undefined back).  

If having a strong, muscular, well-defined back interests you, the following information will enlighten you beyond your wildest dreams (in which case, you likely have some pretty boring dreams).

ANATOMY OF THE BACK

Since the musculature of the back, in its entirety, certainly entails a complex array of varying muscle fibers, I, admittedly, have oversimplified its anatomy below.  Nevertheless, I think if we put our greatest effort into training these particular components of the back, we'll inevitably succeed in achieving our goal - i.e. a ripped-to-shreds back!

Most people would categorize the back muscles into the following 4 sections:  1) the latissimus dorsi; 2) the lower trap fibers; 3) the mid trap fibers; & 4) the upper trap fibers.

1.

2.

3. 

4. 

A comprehensive back workout will hit all of these components of back anatomy, but, more importantly, this back workout will be concise.  So what would such a workout entail?

  • The exercises used will optimally target each component of the back that I've pictured above.
  • The exercises will be done with sufficient volume and intensity to optimally grow type II muscle fibers.
  • The workout will be short, sweet, and to the point.

THE OPTIMAL BACK WORKOUT

The exercises I entail below, I've picked for a number of reasons:  EMG data (EMG data is from here - the credentials of the guy I got this info from can be found here), anecdotal reports, and my personal experience. 

  1. Deadlift: 4 sets of 3-5 reps.  Deadlifts are, hands down, one of the best back builders of all time!  They'll work the upper and mid traps, your grip strength, your spinal erectors, your lats, your glutes, your hamstrings, your core, the sternal head of your pecs, and....on and on forever!  Rack pulls are quite good too. I know the rep scheme for this lift is different from what I prescribed for chest and shoulder workouts, but trust me, if you can do more that 3-5 reps on deadlifts, you're not lifting with enough weight!  If you're grip starts giving out, switch to using a mixed grip, or use straps.
  2. DB Bent-over Row:  4 sets of 4-8 reps.  This is a great exercise for hitting the mid and lower traps.
  3. Chin-up:  4 sets of 4-8 reps.  This exercise is great for hitting both the lats and your biceps!  Anecdotal evidence, and EMG data suggest that chins (done with a supinated grip) will hit the biceps harder than curls!
  4. Chest Supported DB Row:  4 sets of 4-8 reps.  Like the DB bent-over row, this exercise will also target the mid and lower traps; though it will likely put a greater emphasis on the lower traps, whereas the DB bent-over row will better target the mid traps.
Notes - 
  • Warm-up with 1 set of 8 reps at 50% of your target work weight, then do 1 set of 6 reps at 50%, 1 set of 3 reps at 75%, and finally 1 set of 1 rep at 90%.  Rest 1 minute between warm-up sets, and rest 2 minutes before beginning your first work set.  Only do this for the flat bench press (your chest will be plenty warm for the remaining exercises).
  • Rest about 2-3 minutes between work sets.
  • Once you can get the top number of reps for a given exercise, add 5-10lbs of weight, and work with that weight until you can reach the top number of reps again.
NOW GET TO THE GYM AND START PUTTING THIS KNOWLEDGE TO PRACTICE!!!