Tuesday, January 28, 2014

Why I have a Problem with Vegetarianism (Part II: The China Study - Cholesterol, Animal vs Plant Based Foods, & Risk of Cancer)

In Part I of this series, I briefly covered one of the more powerful claims made by T. Colin Campbell in his book The China Study; that claim being that all sources of animal protein are carcinogenic.  While my analysis was far from comprehensive, I hope I was, at the very least, able to convey the fallacy Campbell makes by categorically subsuming all animal sources of protein under the cancer-causing label by using nothing more than some studies done on casein protein in isolation of other variables.  As I stated previously, casein is not representative of all animal sources of protein.  Other sources of animal protein, such as whey, have anti-carcinogenic properties.

This discrepancy demonstrates the dangers of using inductive reasoning (reasoning which starts with a particular observation and, thus, is used to infer general laws and theories).  Indeed, I think many of Campbell's claims are founded on isolated phenomena (and also hubris and observational bias to a certain extent), and, therefore, lead to untenable general conclusions (general conclusions which are not supported by the majority of scientific research).

Don't misunderstand my negative tone for absolute disdain of Campbell's work.  I commend him for his passionate attempt at pointing out many of the flaws which inundate the scientific and Big Pharma industry.  Additionally, I think he is absolutely correct in asserting that the SAD (Standard American Diet) foods we're exposed to, in copious amounts, are tearing away at our health as a nation, and in the West in general.  Nevertheless, I like to call BS when I see it, and BS there is aplenty in many of Campbell's conclusions.

Over the course of the next several days, I'm going to cover a host of issues with The China Study.  I'll be relying heavily upon Denise Minger's critique of Campbell's work, entitled - The China Study: Fact or Fallacy*

*Actually, I'm more or less summarizing her work.  Her knowledge regarding this subject is simply too extensive for me to ignore.

Point #1 of Minger's Critique - Unhealthy Levels of Cholesterol Are Causative of Cancer, and Animal Sources of Food Are to Blame? (Nope!)

I think the heading above adequately conveys Campbell's thesis here.  He believes that having a serum cholesterol level between 90-170 milligrams/deciliter is positively associated cancer mortality.  Moreover, he believes animal protein is causative of this unhealthy cholesterol measurement, and he further believes that plant protein is, inversely, protective against cancer.  But, does the evidence support this hypothesis?  Minger says no.

Where Campbell's Right

According to Minger, Campbell is right on one account.  Animal protein, according to his data, does correlate with higher serum levels of cholesterol.  Moreover, unhealthy levels of cholesterol have been associated with higher risk of cancer.

Where Campbell's Wrong

Minger further points out, however that - 
when we actually track down the direct correlation between animal protein and cancer, there is no statistically significant positive trend. None.
According to Minger, none of the data Campbell uses shows a direct correlation between animal protein and cancer.  In fact, looking at the data, we can see that animal protein was, in actuality, negatively associated with cancer risk in several instances -

Lymphoma: -18
 Penis cancer: -16
 Rectal cancer: -12
 Bladder cancer: -9
 Colorectal cancer: -8
 Leukemia: -5
 Nasopharyngeal: -4
 Cervix cancer: -4
 Colon cancer: -3
 Liver cancer: -3
 Oesophageal cancer: +2
 Brain cancer: +5
 Breast cancer: +12
Note:  (-) Negative numbers indicate a negative association, and (+) positive numbers indicate a positive association.

Though you will likely have noted that animal protein does seem to be correlated (correlation does not logically infer causation) with oesophageal cancer, brain cancer, and breast cancer, there are 10 other types of cancer with which animal protein is negatively associated.

But What About Plant Protein?

Another component of Campbell's hypothesis is that plant protein offers protection against most types of cancer.  This portion of Campbell's hypothesis arises from looking at his initial claim from another angle - 
Cancer associates with cholesterol, cholesterol associates with animal protein, and therefore we infer that animal protein associates with cancer. Or from another angle: Cancer associates with cholesterol, cholesterol negatively associates with plant protein, and therefore we infer plant protein protects against cancer (Minger).
We've already established that the claim incriminating animal protein as causative of cancer is unfounded, but, what of the inverse claim?

Though plant protein does correlate (once again, this does not infer causation) with lower serum levels of cholesterol (according to Campbell's data) -
we also have more positive correlations [between plant protein and cancer] than we saw with animal protein (Minger).
Looking at the data -

Nasopharyngeal cancer: -40**
 Brain cancer: -15
 Liver cancer: -14
 Penis cancer: -4
 Lymphoma: -4
 Bladder cancer: -3
 Breast cancer: +1
 Stomach cancer: +10
 Rectal cancer: +12
 Cervix cancer: +12
 Colon cancer: +13
 Leukemia: +15
 Oesophageal cancer +18
 Colorectal cancer: +19 

Looking at these numbers, we can clearly see that plant protein is more highly correlated (I've said it already, but here it is again, correlation does not mean causation) with risk of cancer than animal protein.

Wait....What!?

That's right, when we look solely at the correlation between protein source and risk of cancer, we have greater reason to indict plant protein.  As Minger states - 
when we look solely at the variable “death from all cancers,” the association with plant protein is +12. With animal protein, it’s only +3. So why is Campbell linking animal protein to cancer, yet implying plant protein is protective against it?
Only Campbell can answer Minger's question, so, rather than put words in Campbell's mouth, I'll let the question stand.

Points of Research Campbell Likely Missed

By putting the bulk of his focus on trying to indict animal protein of high crimes against humanity, Campbell may have missed several other factors which more strongly correlate with elevated cholesterol and cancer.  Minger points to a number of potential factors, such as:  "schistosomiasis infection (correlation of +34*) and hepatitis B infection (correlation of +30*)."

Minger further states - 
Not coincidentally, cholesterol’s strongest cancer links are with liver cancer, rectal cancer, colon cancer, and the sum of all colorectal cancers...[S]chistosomiasis and hepatitis B are the two biggest factors in the occurrence of these diseases. So is it higher cholesterol (by way of animal products) that causes these cancers, or is it a misleading association because areas with high cholesterol are riddled with other cancer risk factors? We can’t know for sure, but it does seem odd that Campbell never points out the latter scenario as a possibility.

In Closing

I will readily admit that Minger's claims hardly exuding total certainty.  As I discussed in a post entitled "The Truth About 'Proof'", science is, by necessity, a tenuous enterprise.  I can't say with total certainty that animal protein is always going to be more or less protective against or causative of cancer in relation to plan protein.  I can only speak in probabilistic terms.

Nevertheless, probabilistically speaking, I would like to assert that there is no strong link between animal protein and cancer.  Additionally, I believe we would be better served by looking at more strongly associable dietary and lifestyle variables and their correlation with disease risk.

Such is my opinion, but I think it's an opinion worthy of our attention.  

Next Time...

In my next post, I'll discus Campbell's claims regarding links between breast cancer and dietary fat.

Sunday, January 26, 2014

Why I Have a Problem with Vegetarianism (Part I: The China Study, Animal Protein, & Cancer)

I could list ad nauseum a number of proliferate dietary myths, misconceptions, and falsities.  Few, however, compare to the meta-fallacy of vegetarianism.

I'll be blunt.  I think veganism/vegetarianism is a poor lifestyle choice, period.

For that matter, I consider any dietary path that requires strict attention to supplementation (by necessity) to be inherently inferior.

I'm not implying, here, that all vegetarian diets are bad per se (the people who have success with vegetarianism know how to supplement their diets properly in order to maintain their health).  I'm merely stating that, if you aren't careful, going vegan/vegetarian can lead to a host of maladies; many of which can be easily avoided by keeping animal products in your diet.

So, in this series of posts I'm going to cover a number of issues with vegetarianism.  Additionally, I'll cover several mistaken conceptions people commonly have regarding animal products.

Let's dig in!

Problems with The China Study - Animal Protein Causes Cancer?

For those unaware, The China Study is a book written by one T. Colin Campbell.  In it, Campbell lays out a "scientific" argument against high protein-animal product based diets.  He, in turn, espouses a low protein-vegetarian diet, basing his claims on research that indicates a causal relationship between animal protein, dietary cholesterol, and high levels of dietary fat with cancer and other sorts of deadly diseases.

Where to Begin?

Let me start off my critique of Campbell's work with a quote from Anthony Colpo (independent researcher, physical conditioning specialist, and author of The Fat Loss Bible and The Great Cholesterol Con) - 
I have read a lot of truly awful health and diet books in my time, but without question, one of the very worst was The China Study by T. Colin Campbell. Never have I read a book so audaciously misleading, one whose author pontificates so vigorously about the importance of the scientific method but then unabashedly proceeds to write page after page of scientifically untenable garbage (1).
Colpo makes some indicting claims here, but are they justified?  What does Colpo mean when he refers to Campbell's work as "scientifically untenable garbage"?  Chris Masterjohn may have an answer -
Campbell [in his book] tells the story like this.  In 1965, he took a faculty position at Virginia Tech, then still an advocate of animal protein as good, nourishing American fare.  In 1967, he accepted an invitation from a department head at that university to travel to the Phillipines with the task of alleviating childhood malnutrition and making sure peanuts could provide good protein without the potential harms of aflatoxin, a carcinogenic mold toxin with which peanuts are often contaminated. 
A shocking revelation then came in two-fold form: first an epidemiological study suggested that liver cancer was rampant among Filipino children and that the “best-fed” rather than the malnourished children were the ones most ravaged by the disease; then, in 1968, ”a research paper from India surfaced in an obscure medical journal” showing that aflatoxin only produced liver cancer in rats when they were fed high levels of casein, a milk protein.  Campbell was surprised and skeptical, but he attempted to replicate these findings, and thus was born his two-decade research program showing that animal protein, but not plant protein, was the single most important trigger that turns cancer “on” like a light switch.
Campbell never tells us, however, that these Indian researchers actually published this paper as part of a two-paper set, one showing that low-casein diets make aflatoxin much more acutely toxic to rats (1), and the other showing that these same diets make aflatoxin much less carcinogenic (2).
In the very paper (2) that Campbell cites as “a revelation to die for,” showing that a high-protein diet turns the cancer switch to the “on” position, the low-protein diet proved lethal to the animals.  The investigators gave rats a small dose of aflatoxin every day for six months and fed them either a 5 percent casein or 20 percent casein diet.  The experiment carried on for two years, in fact, but they stopped administering aflatoxin at six months for the simple reason that half the animals on the low-protein diet had died.  They had typical symptoms of aflatoxin toxicity including liver necrosis (cell death), proliferation of bile duct tissue, and fatty liver. 
All the animals receiving 20 percent casein, on the other hand, were still alive at that point.  For the remainder of the two years [rats are lucky if they live to be 2 years old], the rats receiving 20 percent casein continued to live longer, but many of them developed liver cancer or pre-cancerous changes, while none of the rats fed 5 percent casein developed liver cancer (2).
So....according to the research Campbell elucidates, the only reason a higher protein diet may lead to cancer is because it will allow you to live long enough to get cancer.  Thus, if you want to avoid getting cancer, you should eat a low protein diet so you won't live to see the day that you do get cancer!

What I find most interesting about Campbell's methodology is the lack of nuance.  First off, this study should have been used to assuage people from eating foods containing aflatoxin (i.e. peanuts), not to convince them that they should avoid high protein diets per se.  Moreover, Campbell, epistemologically speaking, could only (at least potentially) have used this research to indict casein as a source of protein.  Admittedly, casein has been associated with a number of autoimmune/cancerous diseases.  However, not all animal sources of protein are casein.  Whey, for example, is an animal protein (one found in milk in addition to casein) that has been shown to have anti-carcinogenic properties.  Rather than pay heed to such a discrepancy with his thesis, however, Campbell asserts in his book that all sources of animal protein are carcinogenic and causative of disease (this is quite the leap in logic given what little data he brings forth).

I think Denise Minger says it best -
As ample literature indicates, other forms of animal protein—particularly whey, another component of milk—may have strong anti-cancer properties. Some studies have examined the effect of whey and casein, side-by-side, on tumor growth and cancer, showing in nearly all cases that these two proteins have dramatically different effects on tumorigenesis (with whey being protective). A study Campbell helped conduct with one of his grad students in the 1980s showed that the cancer-promoting abilities of fish protein depended on what type of fat is consumed alongside it. The relationship between animal protein and cancer is obviously complex, situationally dependent, and bound with other substances found in animal foods—making it impossible extrapolate anything universal from a link between isolated casein and cancer (3).
 Minger further indicates in a separate critique of The China Study -
I propose that Campbell’s hypothesis is not altogether wrong but, more accurately, incomplete. While he has skillfully identified the importance of whole, unprocessed foods in achieving and maintaining health, his focus on wedding animal products with disease has come at the expense of exploring—or even acknowledging—the presence of other diet-disease patterns that may be stronger, more relevant, and ultimately more imperative for public health and nutritional research [such as grain products (Read This), hydrogenated seed and vegetable oils (This), an imbalanced ratio of omega 6-omega 3 fatty acids (This), the over-consumption and over abundance of hyper-rewarding/nutrient deficient foods (and This), etc.] (4).

Looking at the Big Picture

There's certainly more to come in this series (so much to come in fact!), but for now, let's focus on the take home point for today:  We should avoid a reductionist perspective, one which leads us to make unwarranted categorical statements (yes, even my somewhat ignorant rant at the beginning of this post) that ignore the emergent qualities inherent in any given complex system.  Thus, the statement that animal protein is, in and of itself, causative of cancer is epistemologically unfounded, and, moreover, it is blatantly wrong if we consider the fact that whey protein (an animal source of protein) has anti-cancer properties.

Health is not something that we can reduce to any one or small number of factors; rather, it is an emergent system, that being something which is greater than the sum of its parts.

Nevertheless, I still believe there is ample evidence to suggest that a diet lacking in animal sources of nutrition is a more or less unhealthy (or at least sub par) way to go about eating.

So stay tuned for my next post, wherein I will offer a critique of yet another unfounded claim from The China Study.

After that, I'll go on to cover such issues as nutrient deficiencies, and misconceptions about the nutritive value of plants vs. animals (spoiler alert:  diets that consist of just plants or just dead animals are inferior to a diet which contains ample amounts of both plants and dead animals).

Saturday, January 25, 2014

A Critique of Shine's 5 Workout Myths

My Dad recently pointed my attention toward a fitness article on Yahoo Shine entitled "5 Biggest Workout Myths."

Unlike most Yahoo articles out there, I actually agree to a certain extent with what the author states, however, I've decided to go into more detail, and give a fuller picture than what the author of this article did herself.

Here's the article -
Myth #1: Walking is a great way to lose weight. "Going for a walk is fantastic, but if you're in the market for serious weight loss, you're going to have to start changing gears," Michelle says. "Gradually build yourself up." Jogging for 10 minutes burns 100 calories, while walking for the same amount of time burns just 20.
Myth #2: Never work out on an empty stomach. "Training on an empty stomach means that you're going to go straight into your glycemic levels," Michelle explains. "You're going to be burning fat immediately."
Myth # 3: Pilates and yoga are great for weight loss. Michelle says that while these classes improve flexibility, "if you want to lose weight quickly and get fit fast, you need to get into something with a little more intensity."
Myth #4: You shouldn't train with weights every day. Michelle recommends varying what muscles you work and the intensity. "Work on your upper body one day and your lower body the other day," she suggests.
Myth #5: Weight training builds bulk. Michelle says that weight training will provide a great "engine" for burning more fat. "You're going to get a beautiful toned look, but with lean muscle mass, you're going to be burning more calories," she says. (5 Biggest Workout Myths)

Tackling Myth #1

The author, here, is partially right, but mostly wrong (See my post on cardio).  To keep things short and sweet, suffice it to say that walking is in fact a wonderful way to stay active.  Moreover, it most assuredly can lead to fat loss, counter to what the author of the Yahoo article espouses.

The author, additionally, sets the reader up with a false dichotomy by using a comparison between 10 minutes of walking vs 10 minutes of jogging.  Firstly, depending on how fast you go, you can actually burn quite a few calories by walking.  Secondly, I have no idea where the author got her calorie numbers.  Though she's right to say that jogging can burn more calories than walking (depending on the circumstance), I disagree that this calorie comparison is enough to uphold the entire argument.  Interestingly, grand chest masters can purportedly burn up to 6,000-7,000 calories in a day while playing a chess tournament (all the while doing very little physical activity).

I also dislike the fact that the author recommends using walking as a means to work your way up to jogging.  Instead, you ought to stick with walking on a regular basis, and also work on sprinting, or doing some form of high intensity interval training, 1-2x per week.  Sprinting is a more time efficient and metabolically advantageous way to burn calories than jogging ever will be.

Tackling Myth #2

Read this, this, and this to get a more comprehensive take on this subject.  

Also, I think the author of this study should have referred to "fasted training", not training on an empty stomach.  The two are not inherently one in the same.  If you workout about 4 hours after having eaten a meal, you'll be working out on an empty stomach, but you likely won't be in a fasted state (and thus will not likely achieve the "burning fat immediately" scenario the author mentions).  The reason is, depending on the size of your last meal, your body will likely be deriving energy from said meal for several hours post consumption.  You won't start sliding into the fasted state until 6-7 hours after you've eaten (once again, depending on how much you ate).

Moreover, I've also started to shy away from training fasted.  The reason being is that liver glycogen levels will be quite low after even 16 hours of not eating.  If you start doing some sort of high intensity exercise like lifting weights or sprinting with low levels of liver glycogen, you may experience a quick drop in blood sugar, and consequently, your performance.  

Since the liver is tasked with maintaining blood sugar, and since your liver glycogen levels will be rather low, your body will have to start converting its muscle tissue into glycogen in order to maintain healthy blood sugar levels.  This is why, if I do train after a fast, I usually have a piece of whole fruit or a protein shake prior to beginning my workout.  By doing this, I give my body an external, rather than an internal source of glucose or protein that it can use to maintain my blood sugar.

Going back to training on an empty stomach, there's really no one size fits all scenario here.  Some people find it easier to workout with food in their stomach, while others find just the opposite easier.  Genetics, lifestyle, age, and health status all play a role in what will and will not work for you.  Go by your own experience with your body, and not off of my recommendations, or anyone else's.  You should know your body better than anyone.

Tackling Myth #3

While I agree that doing something such as sprinting (or any other high intensity exercise) will offer greater weight loss benefits than yoga or Pilates, don't rule them out just because they don't allow you to burn a lot of calories.  

One study shows that yoga can reduce the symptoms of breast cancer in women.  Yoga can also serve as a type of psycho-therapy, for people with mental illness.

We shouldn't rule out any activity on the basis of calorie burn.  Rather, we should look at the whole host of health benefits achievable.

Tackling Myth #4

While I agree that weight training is a great exercise (well duh!), I don't think it's an activity one should be doing every day.  

There are a lot of contradicting voices out there about how to properly weight train.  One of the voices I listen to says this:
•Work each major bodypart once every 2-7 days. The exact frequency will be determined by factors such as rep range, intensity and exercise selection. These factors, in turn, are influenced by bone-structure and nervous system recovery ability.
•Do 3 'hard' sets per free-weight compound exercise.
•Do 2-3 'hard' sets per isolation exercise.
•The vast majority of your workout should be devoted to free-weight compound exercises. Do relatively few isolation exercises - unless you are genetically gifted, or on drugs, they will not accelerate your progress, they will hinder it.
•Weight train no more than 3 times per week. Large-boned and genetically gifted individuals may progress well on 4 days-per-week split routines, though such high frequency is not necessary to produce optimal strength and size gains..
•Be cautious about, and respectful of, training to failure. Unless you are large-boned/jointed with excellent nervous system recovery abilities, you will likely find that excessive training to failure imposes extended rest periods between body part training sessions, and does not result in faster muscle growth. For small-boned trainees, training to failure must be avoided or done so only on the last set of an exercise. The majority of your sets should end with maybe another one or two reps left in you. (Making A Strength/Size Routine Part IV).
You should be weight training on a regular basis, just don't do it every day.

Tackling Myth #5

Since the author was writing for a female audience (a demographic which mistakenly thinks that weight training will cause them to build unseemly amounts of muscle), this myth is quite pertinent.

Suffice it to say that muscle is built incredibly, incredibly, incredibly slowly.  There is simply no way you could "accidentally" build too much muscle!

Moreover, there is no such difference between lean muscle and bulked muscle.  There are muscles, period!  They can vary in size, but there's only one kind.

Read this article for a more comprehensive take on this subject:  Workout Routines For Women - Why Your Weight Training Workouts Suck

And read this:  Top Three Reasons Women Don't Lift

Conclusion

Whether you're a man or a woman, young or old, there are many myths floating around in cyber space.  If there's a myth you'd like to see me address, let me know in the comments section.